Two Deck Quotes, Two Very Different Scopes: What to Compare
By the Custom Outdoor Structures team · Fairborn, Ohio · Building since 2004 · Updated
Short answer
To compare deck contractor quotes fairly, give each bidder the same project brief and check that each proposal covers the same footprint, decking product, framing, stairs, railing, permits, removal, site work and exclusions. Ask every bidder to explain assumptions and how unexpected conditions or changes are handled.

Make sure every bidder priced the same project
Write down the address, approximate dimensions, intended use, access constraints, existing structure and desired features. Include photos or plans if available. For commercial work, include the property contact, operating hours, public access needs, bid due date and required documents. Give the same information to each bidder.
Ask for specific products and quantities where possible. ‘Composite decking’ or ‘new stairs’ can describe different material lines and scopes. Confirm whether railing, fascia, borders, lighting, demolition, haul-away and restoration are included.
Look for the assumptions hidden beneath the total
Compare the structural scope, footing approach, ledger or freestanding design, stairs and landings, site preparation, drainage, electrical work and permit coordination. List exclusions and allowances. If one proposal leaves a line unclear, request a written answer rather than assuming it matches the others.
Ask how concealed conditions will be handled. A sound process identifies the issue, explains the proposed change and receives approval before additional work proceeds. The proposal should also state how schedule adjustments are communicated.
A quick bid comparison checklist
Compare: exact materials; dimensions and drawings; structural and footing scope; demolition and disposal; stairs, railing and accessories; permits and inspections; access and protection; exclusions and allowances; estimated sequence; payment milestones; change orders; and warranty documents. For commercial bids, confirm document requirements and whether each proposal includes design, engineering, permitting, supply, installation or only selected portions.
Frequently asked questions
- Why can two deck quotes be far apart?
- The proposals may include different materials, structural work, features, site preparation, permitting, exclusions or schedule assumptions. Compare scope line by line before interpreting the price difference.
- What should I send contractors before asking for a quote?
- Share the property address, intended use, approximate size, photos or plans, desired features, access limitations and schedule needs. For a bid, include all issued documents and submission instructions.
- Should I ask for a fixed price?
- Ask what the written price covers, what conditions could change it, and how any change is reviewed and approved. The right contract format depends on the defined scope and project conditions.